Page 1 of 1
Book on AGT
Posted: Sat Dec 31, 2005 4:29 pm
by kate
Hi Everyone,I've just read a review of a book on Alexander - "Alexander the Great, Journey to the End of the Earth" by Norman Cantor, an American historian. Has anyone on the forum read this one? The review was favourable.Best wishes and a Happy New Year to all,Kate
Re: Book on AGT
Posted: Tue Jan 03, 2006 12:17 pm
by jan
Yes, Gail, I have read this book. If one uses the computer at Border's to access books on Alexander, use Arrian's Anabasis and all the books that are available on Alexander will pop up. It appears to be the key to all the available books in the store.Cantor's book is an erudite, concise study, but again he makes the same usual assumptions that modern day scholars seem to enjoy in their discussions. Nothing much new to consider.In Business and Management is a book on Alexander also which uses his various experiences as themes for leadership. It is quite good.
Re: Book on AGT
Posted: Tue Jan 03, 2006 12:17 pm
by jan
Yes, Gail, I have read this book. If one uses the computer at Border's to access books on Alexander, use Arrian's Anabasis and all the books that are available on Alexander will pop up. It appears to be the key to all the available books in the store.Cantor's book is an erudite, concise study, but again he makes the same usual assumptions that modern day scholars seem to enjoy in their discussions. Nothing much new to consider.In Business and Management is a book on Alexander also which uses his various experiences as themes for leadership. It is quite good.
Re: Book on AGT
Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2006 3:41 pm
by rjones2818
Kate,The book is a piece of tripe, for the most part. The map of Alexander's empire shows Alexandria at Siwa, Cantor mistakes the Peloponnesian War for the Persian invasion(s), and several other whoppers.It is bad enough that I would question any other work by the late Mr. Cantor.
Re: Book on AGT
Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2006 3:41 pm
by rjones2818
Kate,The book is a piece of tripe, for the most part. The map of Alexander's empire shows Alexandria at Siwa, Cantor mistakes the Peloponnesian War for the Persian invasion(s), and several other whoppers.It is bad enough that I would question any other work by the late Mr. Cantor.
Re: Book on AGT
Posted: Fri Jan 06, 2006 11:37 am
by kate
Thanks Jan and Rex. Since it doesn't sound as if this book adds anything new I won't buy it, but I might get it out of my local library if they can get hold of a copy for me.Cheers,
Kate
Re: Book on AGT
Posted: Fri Jan 06, 2006 11:37 am
by kate
Thanks Jan and Rex. Since it doesn't sound as if this book adds anything new I won't buy it, but I might get it out of my local library if they can get hold of a copy for me.Cheers,
Kate